I am not a beginner any more. I'd like to learn more. What do you suggest?
There is so much to learn! It is one of the great
pleasures of ancient numismatics. The known history of every ancient
type is extensive, but many types pose questions that remain
Professional scholars and amateurs are researching many fascinating
that remain unresolved. Here I will help you learn how to advance from
"beginner" to an "intermediate," or even "advanced," collector, but
expect it to happen overnight!
(My website for beginners is "Ancient Roman and Greek Coins, FAQ.")
What do you mean by "advanced" collector?
Advanced collectors not only have lots of coins and know what coins cost, but they also know a lot about them. They read serious books and articles. Their knowledge doubles their enjoyment and satisfaction, regardless of how many coins they own or how much they can afford to spend.
People with 100 ancient coins may not be beginners any more, but there is much more to collecting than just buying coins and knowing values. Did you realize that some universities offer Ph.D.'s in ancient numismatics? At Oxford, Cambridge, and several other universities students can train to become experts. Numismatics is a branch of history and scholars write books and articles about ancient coins.
So, there is a great deal of information available beyond the level of "What is it and what is it worth?" There is primary literature written by scholars making an original contribution to knowledge, and there is a great deal of secondary literature (a lot on the web) that is written by people who have read the primary literature and are summarizing it for a wider audience. To progress from novice to intermediate collector you will want to read a lot of secondary literature.
Primary literature includes articles in the major scholarly journals (such as the Numismatic Chronicle which is the journal of the Royal Numismatic Society, the American Journal of Numismatics which is the journal of the American Numismatic Society, and several other important publications in other languages) and some scholarly books.
Secondary literature includes many good books, articles in popular publications like the ancient coin journal The Celator, and information from websites. In fact, almost all the articles in The Celator are written by collectors for collectors. Many advanced collectors (myself included) have written articles or websites about collecting topics that particularly interest them. I have a site for beginners, and below I will mention other sites that emphasize special topics in ancient numismatics.
I see there is a long way to go. I'd just like to learn more -- not get a Ph.D.!
Right. I just wanted you to know it was not just a matter of finding the right book to buy.
How do I go from owning a book or two to the next level?
Most people who buy Roman coins (I'll write about
Greek coins below) want a good
book so they can look up coins and find their values and an ID number.
I'll address this first, even though it is hardly "learning" to simply
look up the ID number of a coin.
If you already have the Sear, Van Meter, or
Vagi price guides, skip ahead past this elementary
discussion of price guides.
The "complete" references to Roman coins are huge
and very expensive. Most collectors settle for a representative list of
types in a "coins and their values" type of book. There are three major
collector's works in English that list Roman coin types.
David Sear, Roman Coins and Their Values,
has been the standard for many years. It is not complete, but gives a
selection of coins. There is a "Millennium" edition (2000) for the
through the twelve caesars. Coins from AD 96 (Nerva) to AD 235 (the end
of the Severans) are in volume 2.
Coins from 235 (Maximinus Thrax) to 285 (Carinus) are in volume 3.
Volume IV covers 284 (Diocletian) to 337 (the death of Constantine). The
of the empire will follow in another volume (issue date unknown, but I
would not expect it before 2014). This
work is expensive (c. $70-80 per volume), but I predict it will be
the standard collector's reference. It has good introductory material,
and numerous short paragraphs on the import of various coin types. I
recommend this book.
If you don't want to spend that much, the earlier single-volume version is very useful and much cheaper (and, goes to the end of the empire, which the others do not yet). It went through several editions, all with the same listings except for the prices and changing from line-drawings to photos after the second edition. Believe it or not, I still love my second edition (1974!) and use it even though it came out in a fourth edition too (which, because of demand, was reprinted in 2004 at about $70). The single-volume editions are far less complete than the new three or four-volume editions, but worthwhile and available at about $35.
David Van Meter, The Handbook of Roman
Coins, has 8000 types
listed (for the empire alone, not for the Republic). It has good
material. The prices are useless, since he only used very wide
"value bands." The lowest band goes all the way from $1 to $100!
It does not distinguish between, say $20 and $80. Hardly much help for
pricing! However, it does have 1000 photos and lots of useful notes on
types and collecting. It was popular in the 1990s but is rare and rarely
used now. It's used price, about $50, is too high for its value and
merely reflects its scarcity.
David L. Vagi, Coinage and History of the
Empire (1999) is a thick and heavy two-volume work, costing c.$115
library edition is more -- I don't know why). One volume is on the
That is probably the most convenient place to get the story of the
I can remember when collectors regularly commented that they wanted to
know much more about the emperors than they could find in Sear's book.
This book has a big volume on the history, so their wants have been
The other volume is on the coins, and it has a ton of information. It
180 pages of notes on types, condition, and other things that affect
values, even before the list of coins and their values! The notes are
reading again and again.(Beginners may find them too advanced to
Then there are another 440 pages listing coins and their values. Wow!
The one objection that many people have is that the list makes no attempt to be comprehensive for the common types. If you buy, say, a coin of Probus, most reverse types are of similar value and only relatively few have special interest that promotes their value to a higher level. Vagi acknowledges this and lumps all common coins of the same ruler denomination under a single reference number. So your coin is likely not to have a distinct "Vagi number." Only especially interesting types get separate numbers. This is frustrating for those who just want a reference number for their coins! (I think that is a substantial majority of collectors. By reading this page, you are showing an interest in moving beyond simply giving coins a number.)
Nevertheless, I recommend this work if you want to learn about coins and history.
So, which of those three is best?
They all have advantages. But I think you will want Sear if you stick with collecting, and Vagi has the most information that will help you learn about coins. Van Meter was, at one time, the cheapest way to get an ID number attached to (most) Roman imperial coins, but its price has gone up and relative value down.
What about ERIC II?
The Encyclopedia of Roman Imperial Coins, second edition, known as ERIC II,
by Rasiel Suarez, is a beautiful and massive 1455-page book that lists
virtually every Roman imperial coin type beginning with Augustus.
Perhaps unexpected from the title is that even the later Roman coins
normally called "Byzantine" are included in the last 200 pages. It costs
about $130. Do not buy the first edition ERIC--if you want one be sure
to get ERIC II, which is far more complete.
It is not a price guide. Types are all described by one small-print line without comment on their historical interest or individual value. Each ruler (or empress, or other relative) is introduced with a short history of his reign and a note on how common or rare his coins are in general, including a rank among the 207 Roman imperial (not including Byzantine) people from most common (Constantine) to rarest (Silbannicus) and a brief comment on typical costs.
The arrangement of the list with over 50,000 entries is necessarily concise. For each emperor all his obverse bust types are listed and given codes as B01, B02, etc. Most are illustrated with a gorgeous image. Then all possible obverse legends are listed and coded -- O01, O02, etc. and all reverse legends are listed and coded R01, R02, etc. All reverse types are listed and coded with T01, T02, etc. and many, including all the common ones, are illustrated, again in color with one side of an excellent example. If more than one mint was issuing coins, a mint code is added, prefixed with M. Types are grouped by denomination and each type gets a single line with a type number among the types of that emperor which includes a date range and RIC and Cohen references. A line describing type #213 of Trajan (a denarius) looks like this:
213) B05, O18, R040, T038, M2 98-99 RIC II 3 C 211
There is a broad gap between the codes and the dates than is, in a small fraction of the cases, filled with additional details of the reverse type such as lettering across the field. The dating is more precise than just the dates of the reign.
Compiling all this information was an unbelievable amount of work. I am really surprised any one person did it!
Color is used very well to color-code part of the outer edges of the pages associated with each emperor, making it easy to identify and turn to pages of coins of a particular emperor.
The illustrations are all of only one side of a coin and all about the same size -- about an inch and an eighth, which is a nice enlargement for most types.
Overall, it is unparalleled as a single-volume list of ancient Roman coins. It does not resemble Vagi's two-volume book because ERIC's history is far less, its list of types is many times as extensive, and it has no prices. Sear's four-volume price-guide series lists the vast majority of types one will encounter, with reverse types listed by legend, not in code, and with individual valuations and occasional very short historical comments. However, it is already four expensive volumes and does not yet cover the entire Roman imperial series. (Sear's "Byzantine Coins and Their Values" is complete.) Van Meter's book, popular in the 1990s, is rarely used or cited anymore.
Can you recommend ancient Roman coin books that are not price guides?
Yes. Here are some excellent books designed to take you from novice to serious student of ancient coins.
Coinage in the Roman World by Andrew Burnett is packed with information from one the world's top scholars (and, former Curator of the British Museum collection). In summary form, it incorporates all of the most recent scholarship on Roman coinage from its beginnings to the end of the empire. It has chapters on mint authority, monetary history, designs and propaganda, circulation and function, inflation, the coming of Christianity, and the transition to medieval coinage. It is only 168 pages plus plates of 187 coins, but a super book. This would be my top recommendation.
Many collectors want to know about the role of coins in the economy. What were they worth? What about taxes? How much did the government spend? Coinage in the Roman Economy, 300 BC to AD 700, by Kenneth Harl, has 500 pages of answers to questions like these, and excellent photographs of 267 important coin types. He has gathered together in one volume the results of a large number of research articles and incorporated them into a single, flowing, account. This book is very informative. I have some criticisms of details, but no work of this scope could avoid controversy. (In particular, I think his discussion of the denominations of the coins AD270 - 310 is too assertive. There are many dissenting opinions that he fails to represent.) However, this book will give you a good idea of the complexity of the subject and what the evidence looks like. It is very scholarly and not for beginners, but it is highly recommended.
Richard Reece, Coinage in Roman Britain, is written by a top English scholar. In the same series as the Burnett book, it goes into detail about what is found in Britain. It has chapters on production, coins in Britain, use of coins, hoards, site-finds, supply and circulation, and more. Only 144 pages with pictures of 44 coins and many graphs, it will nevertheless tell you a great deal about coins in Roman times.
A Dictionary of Ancient Roman Coins by John Melville Jones explains the terms you will see in conjunction with coins. Who is "Fortuna"? What is the history of the "sestertius"? It's in there. A very good book.
Christopher Howgego, Ancient History from Coins, is packed with information about ancient Greek and Roman coins and how they relate to history. Howgego is a leading scholar and crams a ton of information into not very many pages (176 pages with 184 coins photographed beautifully). His extensive footnotes lead you to the publications that discuss matters in greater detail. This book is "over the head" of novices, but can be read many times with increasing comprehension. If you want to glimpse the scholarly side of ancient coins, this is a great way to do it.
Coins and the Archaeologist, edited by John Casey and Richard Reece, is a collection of 14 scholarly articles on coinage with emphasis on coins from Roman Britain. It also has the finest single article on ancient imitations (87 pages on imitations and 165 coins pictured!). It has articles on Romano-British hoards, interpretation of site finds, numerical aspects of hoards, dating, interpreting coin finds, and more. This, too, may be "over the head" of the novice.
Roman Coins, by Harold Mattingly, was the finest book of its kind for many years. Mattingly was the most prominent scholar of Roman coins at the time, and he initiated and edited the first volumes of RIC. The first edition of Roman Coins was published in 1928 and the second (and last) edition was published in 1960. It has 64 plates of Roman coins, organized by theme rather than by emperor. It is not a list of coins by any means, rather a serious scholarly discussion of financial administration, chronology and mints, types (arranged by principle, not date), coinage and life, provincial coinage, reforms, etc. It is very informative and well worth reading, but it is definitely not a list of coins you can cite. It is not for the beginner because the organization is based on general principles that become apparent only after you have seen a lot of Roman coins.
Roman Coins, by J. P. C. Kent and Max and Albert Hirmer is a spectacular coffee-table book with excellent commentary besides. It illustrates, with truly superb photographs, 785 of the finest Roman coins known. Kent was Curator of Coins in the British Museum and wrote a very good summary of the history of Roman coinage, but it is hard to tear your eyes away from the photographs! Expensive, but worth it if you can afford it.
Many collectors enjoy A Dictionary of Roman
by Seth Stevenson. A massive 929-page work published in 1889 (but
written c. 1850), it has been reprinted and is not hard to find. It has
a quaint 19th century style more than compensated for by its extremely
thorough listing of types, legends, attributes, and any other term that
might come up in conjunction with Roman coins. Melville-Jones's
mentioned above, does not attempt to list legends and is more up to
but Stevenson's book is undoubtedly fun to read.
Those of us who like late
Roman bronze of the tetrarchy and
Constantinian period like Victor
Failmezger's Roman Bronze Coins:
From Pagnism to Christianity, 294-364 AD, with a comprehensive
listing and 42 color page plates illustrating over 600 coins. I
love the list and photos best, but there is tons of additional
information about history, mints, field marks, legends translated,
details of commonly-collected types, etc. Highly recommended.
What about Ancient Coin Collecting Vol. III: The Roman World - Politics and Propaganda, by Wayne Sayles?
It is the most available introductory book, but I don't think it is organized to make it easy to understand Roman coins. Also, I don't like the use of so many photos of only the portrait side of the coin. The fascinating reverses are almost entirely neglected. Coins have two sides and beginners need to see what reverses look like and how meaningful they can be. However, this webpage is designed to discuss higher-level books to buy after you have read a book like that one. I think of it as a beginner's book, not intended for collectors who are already knowledgeable. Neither is Klawans book, Reading and Dating Roman Imperial Coins, recently reprinted as the Roman half of Handbook of Ancient Greek and Roman Coins. That is a good beginners book (and I began with it), but it has no pretense to scholarship.
I have heard of RIC and BMC. What are they?
RIC and BMC are the two nearly-complete references for Roman imperial coins. They are the ultimate lists of Roman imperial coins. Furthermore, they are the "last word" short of more-recent articles. Advanced collectors have at least the volumes for the time period they are interested in.
RIC (pronounced as three letters, "R-I-C") stands for Roman Imperial Coinage. Published in 10 volumes (13 books), it is a massive work (17 inches of shelf space!) that is the only (very nearly) complete list of Roman imperial coins. It does not include Roman Republican coins. Each volume has a long discussion of the history of coinage of the period. If you have a Roman imperial coin, it is almost certain to be somewhere in RIC, with a date as close as possible. Although it has quite a few photographs, it is very far from fully illustrated. Published over a span of 70 years (!), some volumes are showing their age. Volumes I (to AD 69), II.1 (69-96 AD, the Flavians), VIII (sons of Constantine), and X (post Theodosius) are very up to date, and there is no easy way to find anything better for the period 238-337 AD, but BMC is better for the period 96-238 AD. Needless to say, it is very expensive.
BMC (pronounced as three letters, "B-M-C"
or "BMC Roman") stands
Museum Catalog and there is one for Roman imperial coins (as well
others for Greek and Republican coins). It is six volumes (in 8 thick
-- another 17 inches of shelf space! It quits at 238 AD and will
never be continued to cover the Gordians or later emperors.
BMC is much preferable to RIC for the period 96-238. (RIC I and II.1 are up-to-date cover through the Flavians very well). BMC is better because it is newer, has much more discussion of the history and types, and has almost complete photographic coverage of the types. If you want ID numbers, notes, and photos, BMC is the catalog for you. Needless to say, it is very expensive.
What are some Republican coin references?
The 2000 "Millennium" edition of Sear's Roman Coins and Their Values, volume 1, has virtually complete list of Republican types. Also, many types are explained in short paragraphs. This is in contrast to previous editions in which explanation was sparse. Nevertheless, the book is still primarily a list, although you will learn so much from it that you should own it. I highly recommend this book in the "Millennium" edition.
Roman Silver Coins, I, Republic to Augustus,
by H. A. Seaby, in the Seaby series and revised by David
and Robert Loosely, is a (virtually) complete one-volume list of Roman
silver (but not AE or gold) coins. It is organized by
moneyer's "family", not chronologically, but there are all in there
values, and most coins you could buy have excellent photographs.
Is has recently been reprinted and I have seen it new for $46. It will
you an ID number for your coin and occasionally tell you one line (not
more) about a type. I recommend it if you want to concentrate on
Republican coins. I find it very useful when someone cites a Republican
coin by family name but not the date or Crawford number.
If you want the best, your choice is clear. Roman
Coinage by Michael Crawford is the standard reference. A
huge 2-volume work, it will cost you $350 or more. But, it has most of
what there is to know about Republican coins. It is both a complete
with type numbers, and an extensive discussion of everything relating
Republican coins, often in great depth. Beginners will use the
numbers and gradually learn that the rest is extremely valuable and
fascinating. By the way, Crawford omitted most of the amusing anecdotes
about the moneyers because they were already published in BMC Roman Republican by Grueber.
For another $250 or so you can get the stories in 3-volume very old
book with outdated dating of the issues.
The Coinage of the Roman Republic, by Sydenham, was written long ago but is still available in reprint (with reduced size, so the photographs are all too small!). It is outdated, with important dates we now know to be wrong. Skip it.
If your interest is in the imperators (during the transition from the Republic to the empire) you are in luck. David Sear has written The History and Coinage of the Roman Imperators 49 BC - 27 BC, which is about as complete as you could ever wish for. If you want to know a lot about your coins and the time period, this is the last word, and it includes a price guide too. It costs about $95 and is well worth it.
If your Republican coin was minted between 63 and
49 BC, there is a good work by Michael Harlan, Roman
Moneyers and Their Coins, 63 BC - 49 BC, which tells the entire
of each type (up to five pages on a single type!) and as much as is
about the moneyers. The editors did not organize the pictures well, but
the types are illustrated. It is a pity that the rest of the Republican
series does not have such excellent sources as these last two. Harlen recently (2012) self-published a companion volume, Roman Republican Moneyers and Their Coins, 81 BCE - 64 BCE,
and did a much better job than Seaby at illustrating the types. If you
have any Republican coins from that time period it is an excellent book.
The early huge bronze issues are listed and illustrated in Bradbury Thurlow's Italian Cast Coinage, Italian Aes Grave (printed together with Italo Vecchi's Italian Aes Rude, Signatum and the Aes Grave of Sicily). It has 34 pages of discussion and even lists the numbers of examples of each known at one time. It is an advanced book.
If you like the late Republic, but not just Republican coins, Crawford's Coinage and Money under the Roman Republic is an amazing work of scholarship that chronicles, in every geographical region, the transition from coins before the Romans to Republican coinage. All those tiny kingdoms are discussed. It has some assertions that may need correction in detail, but it certainly is a good series of articles on the period. Unfortunately, although there are many photos, most are poor photos of casts and not well identified. I happen to love this book, but it is certainly not for beginners!
I am cleaning coins and trying to identify them. Is there a good book for me to learn identification skills?
Yes, if you are identifying late Roman bronzes.
is a page recommending book by
Bruck which is sometimes offered on German
eBay. Now its ideas have been put on the web at "Identifying Late
Roman Bronze Coins:" http://www.tesorillo.com/aes/home.htm
What about Greek coins?
The subject of of Greek coins is far more
complicated than Roman coins. There are perhaps 500 cities that minted
coins in the Greek world, and many kingdoms and dynasties that are
treated as "Greek" merely because they were not Roman.
Greek Coins by John Anthony is a well-illustrated and
inexpensive introduction. It is not a price guide, and not quite a "how
collect" book either, but it discusses the coins of the most
prominent city-states (Athens, Corinth, Syracuse, etc.), the
Hellenistic Kingdoms, the East, and has a chapter on thematic
collecting. I recommend it.
An Outline of
Ancient Greek Coins by Zander Klawans is a 1982 book with lots
of information, but not as expository as the Anthony book. It really is
more of an "outline" with one coin of each of many cities illustrated
and about 35 pages of basic introduction. This is a very basic book. I
Collecting II: Numismatic Art of the Greek World, by Wayne
Sayles (1997), is probably the most available introduction, but I don't
think it is easy to begin Greek coins by reading that book. It has many
photographs of top pieces. Among other things,
I don't like the way so many coins are illustrated with only the
Ian Carradice (1995) is an excellent slim (112 pages) introduction to
important Greek precious metal coins with many excellent B&W
tracks the history of the coins as changes occur in the Greek world. If
you want to see what a superb and representative collection of Greek
silver would look like, this could show you the ideal. It is written by
a serious scholar for serious students and has no advice about
collecting. If I just wanted to show someone what Greek coins are like
and how they fit into the ancient world, I'd buy them this book. (It is
about $20 from the David Brown Book Company.)
Coinage in the
Greek World, by Ian Carradice and Martin Price (1998), is and
excellent work, very well suited to beginners and advanced collectors
alike. Written by two top scholars, it is completely
authoritative. Nevertheless, it is completely user-friendly. It is not
to collect" guide, but a chronologically organized well-illustrated
ancient Greek coins. This is an outstandingly good book, but is now
hard to find in the U.S. (Although at this writing vcoins.com has some
copies and you can order it from England.) If you are thinking of
collecting Greek coins, buy this book.
is easy to start
with, but, no matter how far you advance, you will never outgrow it.
These previous two would satisfy serious scholars
with the accuracy and organization of the introduction to ancient Greek
[I intend to review Greek coin books that are more
expensive or more advanced, but that will occur later.]
Are you only going to recommend books?
No, I am going to recommend articles and websites
(below), and here I need to mention sale catalogs. If you want to know
about market value of high-end coins, what excellent condition is, and
how "rare" coins are there is no better way (short of going to major
shows) than to read lots of sale catalogs. Dealers put lots of effort
making catalogs entertaining, and you can learn a great deal by reading
sale catalogs and examining their pictures of coins. For example, a
US firm is CNG (Classical Numismatic Group). They have published over
fine auction catalogs, the recent ones with over 2000 coins described
photographed. A single CNG catalog has far more photographs than most
books! And, you would learn a lot about whole series of coins that are
not in your chosen area. What a great way to expand your horizons!
There are several other high-quality auction firms in the US and especially Europe that publish auction sale catalogs. I think their reference value exceeds their actual cost. But, beginners seem to want to find their own coins in some list so they can give their coins ID numbers. Sale catalogs will have a wide and fascinating selection of coins, but they won't serve as a comprehensive list. However, if you advance beyond the "list" stage of collecting, you will want to own some sale catalogs. I started to buy back issues of important sale catalogs after I got a few of the major reference books.
Are there other books on Roman coins you would recommend?
Yes. Roman Coins, by C. H. V. Sutherland, is a beautiful book by a major scholar. It has 572 excellent enlargements and even color plates of coins. There is little emphasis on common late Roman coins. He was a major contributor to our knowledge of the early imperial coins, and it shows in his choice of material. It is not a list of coins, rather a history of Roman coinage.
Coins of the Roman Empire, by R. A. G. Carson, is a very thorough chronological discussion of of coinage history under the empire, plus an extensive discussion of coin output and mint techniques. But it is not a pleasure to read because it is primarily a list of details strung end-to-end without a clarifying overview. It has good photos of 980 coins. Originally about $200 in a boxed volume, now it seems to go for less when it can be found.
Roman History from Coins, by Michael Grant, is a small book with a neat theme. In 92 pages and 32 page plates he discusses coins that can be connected to history. Many authors have questioned his (over)emphasis on Roman anniversaries, but for those of us that like to see the relationship between coins and history, this is a good place to start.
Roman Historical Coins, by Clive Foss, is a long list of almost every Roman coin that can be directly connected to some event. It has over 300 pages of very concise entries! But, that does not leave much room to discuss individual issues, so the format is to give a short history of each emperor, citing the numbers of types that correspond to the events mentioned. I like the idea, but I can't say it is a book to read -- it is primarily a book to consult.
If your interest is in the twelve Caesars (Julius Caesar - Domitian), Sutherland wrote two similar books on their coins, Coinage in Roman Imperial Policy (1951) and The Emperor and the Coinage (1976). These are two good works intended for scholars (not really for collectors), but advanced collectors will find them interesting.
My favorite introduction to Roman imperial coins is virtually unavailable, but I can't resist mentioning it. John Fox's Roman Coins and How to Collect Them is a pure delight. A teacher on a low budget in England, he tells many fascinating stories about collecting. It is very well-illustrated by hundreds of photos of (mostly low grade) coins he bought or traded for at coin shows. Unlike any other coin book, most of the coins are identified not only by emperor and type, but also by when, and for how much, he bought them, for example "2 pounds, 1979". I read it six times in the first two years I owned it, and reread the whole thing with great pleasure recently. If you collect only high grade coins, you will still love his style and stories. If you collect purely for the interest of the coins, regardless of grade, this book is up your alley! I wish it were in print!
I'm interested in "Greek imperial" coins.
Greek imperials (so named for the Greek
on coins minted in Roman imperial times) are beginning to be
known as "Roman Provincial."
This is a huge and difficult, but very interesting, subject. No one book will get you very far. Greek Imperial Coins and Their Values by David Sear (Sear again!) is the only one-volume list-style reference. It lists 6000 coins and has many pages of helpful notes, but the great majority of Greek imperial coins you buy will not be exactly in there. The field is too vast to be well-covered by a list of only 6000 types! But it is a very good book within that limitation.
Roman Provincial Coins: An Introduction to
Greek Imperials, by Kevin Butcher, is an excellent introduction
a great deal of "meat". It can be read again and again. A slim book, it
has excellent photographs of 95 coins and many more line drawings. I
have already read it 7 times, and scanned it many more, and I still
it. If you might be interested in Roman Provincial coins, buy this book.
Ancient Coin Collecting IV: Roman Provincial Coins, by Wayne Sayles, is an attractive beginner's book. It will give you some picture of what is out there in the field. The illustrations are of very high grade coins that are quite exceptional. This is unfortunate, because collectors will find that it is almost impossible to collect coins like those. It is an okay place to begin, but you could begin with Butcher's fine work which is better and will take you further into this complex field.
If you would like to know more about the cities
which your Roman provincial coins were minted, I strongly recommend
Grant's A Guide to the Ancient World which is a 728-page
listing of ancient cities and facts about them. It has recently been
by Barnes and Noble, so it is not as expensive as such a massive work
What about other books?
Dennis Kroh has written a survey of books on ancient coins, Ancient Coin Reference Reviews, with each book evaluated (and given 0 to 5 stars) and priced. This useful book costs about $25.
Books and more books! You mentioned articles.
Yes, I did. Many collectors subscribe to the monthly ancient coin journal, The Celator, which each month has a few articles written by advanced collectors for other collectors, as well as a large number of market reports and dealer ads. Any given month there may be nothing to interest you, but more articles keep appearing and soon you will find something very interesting. Getting back issues (or yearly summary issues called The Best of the Celator) would be a good way to learn a lot.
If you can get to a major library, you might find
the Numismatic Chronicle or the American Journal of
and scan the contents for articles of interest. Many of my friends and
I belong to the Royal Numismatic Society and the American Numismatic
and these journals are the primary benefits of membership.
What about articles on the web?
There are many good ones. I list some below, but
first here are some thoughts.
The best ancient coin sites on the web for serious learning about Roman coins are those written by Doug Smith. He has posted over 100 excellent articles on everything from how to grade coins and a glossary of terms, to detailed articles on particular coins. Wow! I love his work. Some of his articles are on basic things every collector needs to know, and others are pretty sophisticated discussions of particular fascinating coins or coin types that you may not care much about (until you own one!). His sites on at the top of my annotated list of sites. Keep in mind I have not indexed his sites, so look over his tables of contents too.
My annotated list of sites is here.
I'm interested in ancient imitations - fourres, etc. Where can I learn about them?
I have written a web page about scholarly articles on ancient imitations and a site on Ancient Imitations of Roman Coins.
If I want to do real research, where can I start?
At the advanced level, the ANS (American
Society) has an indexed list of (almost) all serious published articles
on ancient coins on line at
You can search for just about any thing, for example, emperor "Hadrian", and see the titles and abstracts of articles that mention "Hadrian" somewhere in the abstract. This is not an easy approach, though, because you will find far too much material at a very detailed level. It is more for going from "intermediate" to "advanced" collector.
Where can I buy these books you recommend?
The toughest question! Some are still in print and available from major ancient coin dealers. The best place to begin is with the dealers at vcoins.com . But many are out of print and hard to find. Some used book dealers occasionally have them. Maybe you could search the web. You will find that good books retain their value as well as or even better than good coins!
I hope this site has been of some use to you.
-- Warren Esty
e-mail me at:
Note well: Please do not ask me to answer your research questions individually (I have a life!). However, if you wish me to review a certain Roman coin book, write and tell me and I may add a review of it to this site.
Posted 6/26/2000. Revised 12/17/2012.
Return to the main site (page 3) on Ancient
and Greek Coins, FAQ.